A $52 ​​Billion Proposal Aims to Protect New York Harbor From Storm Surges

Author: Yuvi September 27, 2022

A $52 ​​Billion Proposal Aims to Protect New York Harbor From Storm Surges


Almost 10 years after Hurricane Sandy’s floods devastated coastal New York and New Jersey, the US Army Corps of Engineers has unveiled its latest vision of how to protect the region from future storms: a $52 billion proposal to build 12 movable sea barriers across the mouths of major bays and inlets along New York Harbor.

The plan would be by far the region’s largest project to address storms that are growing more frequent and intense as the planet warms from the burning of fossil fuels and the only one attempting to defend the whole New York Harbor region. If Congress approved the proposal, the federal government would pay 65 percent of the cost.

It will also undoubtedly reignite a debate over the right approach to a complex problem — managing flood risks related to climate change, which is expected to raise sea levels one to six feet by the end of the century.

It was scuttled after President Donald J. Trump criticized the plan, which at one point carried a cost estimate of $119 billion and which some experts said could harm the environment and might not even work.

Since then, the fiscal impact of the coronavirus pandemic has only toughened the political and financial challenges of devising solutions to the interrelated risks of storm surges, flash flooding and rising sea levels that threaten the New York region and waterfront cities around the world.

The new Army Corps proposal would include a series of sea gates — movable walls to be closed only for major storms — that would block waterways around Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island and New Jersey, along with 31 miles of land-based levees, elevated shorelines and sea walls. It would require approval from the state and local governments that would foot the rest of the bill.

The proposal — like its predecessor — lands squarely in a broader resiliency debate, over how much to rely on each of two approaches that most experts think will have to be combined. One relies on engineered solutions, like building sea barriers that try to control water flows, along with walls and levees that defend coastlines. The other approach focuses on remaking waterfront areas so that they are more compatible with rising seas and intensifying weather: restoring marshlands, relocating some communities and redesigning others.

The Army Corps proposal would do some of each approach and has been revised to take into account public concerns, but its focus remains on sea barriers and walls. The Corps estimates it would be finished by 2044 and would save an average of $6.2 billion in flood damage a year for the next five decades.

Those who were skeptical of the previous proposal called the new one a major improvement, but want the Corps to further reduce reliance on built structures that may not keep up with the forces of nature and that pose risks to coastal ecosystems.

Some experts have warned the new structures might even worsen floods by deflecting surges elsewhere, slowing storm water drainage or trapping toxins and sewage in waterways known for pollution, such as Newtown Creek and Gowanus Canal, both Superfund cleanup sites.

“It’s not to say that there can be no sea barriers,” said Tyler Taba, senior manager for climate policy at the Waterfront Alliance, a consortium of organizations in the region. “But it’s critical that green and natural infrastructure should be the primary consideration.”

In a statement, the Alliance called for more consideration of buying out flood-prone homes, elevating or relocating infrastructure and working on natural and societal solutions. Mr. Taba added that the Corps should do more to engage those most affected than it did last time, when 705 people showed up for public meetings on a project affecting 16 million residents.

Rob Freudenberg, vice president for energy and environment at the Regional Plan Association, said the Army Corps had already become more responsive to public concerns and that the new proposal’s public comment period, through Jan. 6, 2023, offered a chance for a more informed public debate.

“This is a good opportunity now to take more time to learn about what all this includes and let each community that’s on the map weigh in,” Freudenberg said.

Those communities include New York’s five boroughs and nearby towns in New Jersey and Long Island.

Sea gates are proposed for Flushing and Newtown Creeks, the mouth of Jamaica Bay and two waterways near Howard Beach in Queens; the Gowanus Canal, Sheepshead Bay, Gerritsen and Coney Island Creek in Brooklyn; the Arthur Kill and Kill Van Kull between Staten Island and New Jersey, and the Hackensack River in New Jersey.

Land-based barriers, elevated promenades or sea walls would be built from Bath Beach in Brooklyn to Far Rockaway in Queens, and along stretches of Lower Manhattan, East Harlem and Jersey City.

A final design is expected in 2025, and construction would start in 2030.

27 September, 2022, 5:44 am

News Cinema on twitter News Cinema on facebook

Tuesday, 27th September 2022

More Stories
Pamela Rosenkranz Wins the High Line Plinth’s Third Commission
Royal Family news LIVE: William and Kate land in Boston for a three-day visit to the US
Powell says that rates will rise more and remain high ‘for some time.’
San Francisco Considers Allowing Use of Deadly Robots by Police
Life Science, Spacewalk Preps as Station Orbits Higher
NATO Nations Grow More Receptive to US Pleas to Confront China
Prince William and Kate Middleton land in Boston for US trip amid royal race row
New York Police Name a Chief Who Has Faced Internal Discipline
South Africa’s President, Cyril Ramaphosa, Faces Impeachment Hearing
Mother sparks furious debate after waxing her 10-year-old daughter’s face
Outcome in Oath Keepers Trial Could Hold Lessons for Coming Jan. 6 Cases
Elon Musk’s Neuralink to share progress of its brain chip tonight
Sam Brinton: Biden’s nuclear waste guru spoke at a spanking seminar weeks after bag theft
Could Theatrical Movies Shut Out Streamers for the Top Oscars?
17 Public Employees Charged in Schemes to Steal Covid Relief Funds
Deaths From Substance Abuse Rise Sharply Among Older Americans in 2020
White House ‘deeply concerned’ about Paul Whelan
‘Philadelphia is a war zone’: thug strolls up to parking official and shoots him in the head
Indian-origin doc slams ‘racist joke’ at British Curry Awards
Argentina’s World Cup Hangs in the Balance Against Poland
China completes world’s largest solar telescope array with 1.9-mile-wide ring of 313 dishes
Bigg Boss 16 Day 60 Updates: Housemates call Nimrit unfair for favoring Shiv and Soundarya in ranking task
FIFA World Cup 2022: Defending champion France lost to Tunisia
Mariah Carey offers fans opportunity to stay in her apartment BUT the star won’t even be there
House PASSES bill to stop a rail strike on December 9 after Biden asked Congress to step in
In Georgia, Walker’s Pace in the Finish Worries Republican Allies
Hiroshi Miyamura, Given Medal of Honor in Korean War, Dies at 97
Cops kill Illinois man and his grandpa while trying to stop younger man from stabbing his relative
A Resonant Topic in Georgia’s Senate Runoff: Insulin Prices
Spotify Wrapped drops but Apple Music Replay fans have it trending
The five ‘saboteurs’ trying to derail Kevin McCarthy’s Speaker bid: GOP leader’s allies push back
Biden gives 11 tribes $135M to move coastal buildings to higher ground due to climate change
FIFA World Cup 2022: Lionel Messi’s Argentina qualification scenario ahead of must-win clash vs Poland
MDMA could be approved for PTSD in the US by 2024
Moment Litvinenko said he’d been poisoned recreated for ITVX drama widow says keeps his voice alive
Layoffs Hit CNN as Cost-Cutting Pressure Mounts
In a Show of Unity, House Democrats Elect Hakeem Jeffries Minority Leader
Hit by sanctions over Ukraine war, Russia turns to India for products in its key sectors
Abhishek Banerjee, on Amitabh Bachchan as his role model, says ‘I want to do what he did in Deewar’
Verdict in Trump Organization Trial Could Come Down to 3 Little Words
Twitter’s former head of security says platform is LESS safe under Elon Musk and decries layoffs
Some Rail Workers, Seeking Sick Days, Say Biden Betrayed Them