A Huge Merger’s Collapse Breaks a Pattern of Consolidation in Publishing

Author: Yuvi November 22, 2022

A Huge Merger's Collapse Breaks a Pattern of Consolidation in Publishing


After two years of regulatory scrutiny and heated speculation in the publishing world, after a hard-fought court battle and hundreds of millions of dollars in expenses, Penguin Random House’s deal to buy Simon & Schuster officially collapsed on Monday.

The unraveling of this agreement stopped the largest publisher in the United States from growing substantially larger. It also paused consolidation in an industry that has been profoundly reshaped by mergers and acquisitions, with little regulatory intervention.

The implosion of the deal came three weeks after a federal judge ruled against Penguin Random House in an antitrust trial, blocking the sale from going forward on the grounds that the merger would be bad for competition and harmful to authors. In order to appeal the Oct. 31 ruling, Penguin Random House needed Paramount Global, Simon & Schuster’s parent company, to extend the purchase agreement, which expires on Tuesday. Instead, Paramount decided to terminate the deal, leaving Penguin Random House out of legal options and obligated to pay them a termination fee of $200 million.

“Penguin Random House remains convinced that it is the best home for Simon & Schuster’s employees and authors,” Penguin Random House said in a statement. “We believe the judge’s ruling is wrong and planned to appeal the decision, confident we could make a compelling and persuasive argument to reverse the lower court ruling on appeal. However, we have to accept Paramount’s decision not to move forward.”

The outcome of the trial came as a shock to many in publishing, who have watched the number of big firms dwindle to five, even as those five — Penguin Random House, HarperCollins, Macmillan, Hachette and Simon & Schuster — got larger by buying small. and midsize publishing houses. Many feared that a further reduction in the number of big publishing houses to four would leave authors and literary agents with fewer buyers for their books, and would make it even harder for smaller publishers to compete.

Many were especially wary of Penguin Random House—already by far the largest publisher in the United States—getting even bigger by absorbing a rival. Penguin Random House has about 100 prints; together they publish more than 2,000 titles a year. The merger would have given it Simon & Schuster’s approximately 50 imprints, as well as the company’s vast and valuable backlist of older titles.

As it turned out, the Justice Department and the judge who heard the case had similar concerns and blocked the deal, an outcome that some authors and industry organizations celebrated as a necessary check on consolidation.

“The market is already too consolidated,” said Mary Rasenberger, chief executive of the Authors Guild, an advocacy group for writers that opposed the purchase. “A healthy publishing ecosystem is one that has many publishers with different tastes and interests and degrees of risk they’re willing to assume.”

This extends a period of uncertainty at Simon & Schuster, but it is one they are in a good position to navigate. The company’s recent performance has been strong, even as the results have sagged at other major publishers. Its profits for the first nine months of the year were up 29 percent compared to the same time last year, putting it on its way to having a record-breaking year.

Among its successes are several novels by Colleen Hoover, who have dominated the fiction best seller lists, and a surprise best selling memoir, “I’m Glad My Mom Died,” by Jennette McCurdy, which has sold a million copies since it was published in August, the company said.

In a statement released Monday afternoon, Paramount indicated that it views Simon & Schuster as not a good fit for its broader strategy. “Simon & Schuster is a highly valuable business with a recent record of strong performance, however it is not video-based and therefore does not fit strategically within Paramount’s broader portfolio,” it said.

It’s unclear, however, whether the headache and the legal expense of the trial could dampen the enthusiasm of other publishers. During the trial, executives for two other major publishing houses, Hachette and HarperCollins, testified that they would like their own companies to buy Simon & Schuster. It is also unclear how the Justice Department would view such an acquisition. Concerns about market share would be less pronounced—particularly for Hachette, which is significantly smaller than Penguin Random House—but the number of publishers big enough to compete on the most expensive books would still drop from five to four.

Some antitrust experts said that any deal to sell Simon & Schuster to another Big Five publisher would likely face intense scrutiny from regulators.

“If anybody else wants to put in a bid, they should put that into their calculation, here’s the cost of litigating this with the government,” said Erik Gordon, a professor of business at the University of Michigan.

The end of the deal also signals a period of uncertainty for Penguin Random House. Penguin Random House revealed at trial that it has been losing market share in recent years. It had hoped that buying Simon & Schuster would make up for that slippage. Now, it will have to find another way.

22 November, 2022, 3:00 am

News Cinema on twitter News Cinema on facebook

Tuesday, 22nd November 2022

More Stories
A Russian Journalist’s Reference to Russian Troops Causes Fury and Soul Searching
Queen was privately ‘devastated’ by Prince Harry and Meghan Markle lashing out at the royal family
Gmail creator predicts total disruption for Google as chatbot ChatGPT challenges tech giant monopoly
World Test Championship 2023: Pakistan’s defeat puts India in driver’s seat to reach final, here’s why
Shylah Rodden’s Melbourne Royal Show rollercoaster crash sees ride operator quit carnivals
Pakistani Actress Hania Ameer Mobbed By Unruly Crowd, Actress Loses Her Cool – Watch Viral Video
After swimsuit look, Priyanka Chopra stuns in hot pink gown for Bulgari event in Dubai – pics
Black and Spanish: A National Team Starts to Reflect All of Its Nation
Cruise ship passengers open up about the moment a rogue wave struck the vessel killing American woman
They thought I was fat: Shilpa Shirodkar reveals why she lost ‘Saiya Saiya’ to Malaika Arora
Hansika Motwani looks radiant in a red bridal lehenga and finally shares her wedding clicks with husband Sohail Katuria!
Kirstie Alley’s death prompts social media users to Tweet ‘you had a good go at it’
Amidst Balenciaga’s controversial ad campaign, Malacca Aurora was party-shy wearing the brand’s dress!
Kirstie Alley’s final TV appearance: Late actress starred on The Masked Singer in April
Kirstie Alley once pined for her costars John Travolta and Patrick Swayze
Happy Birthday Jasprit Bumrah: Watch wife Sanjana Ganesan’s romantic message on the pacer’s special day
‘Drop Dead Gorgeous’ actor Kirsty Alley dies aged 71 after battle with cancer
Why this plain photo of a household bin sitting on a kerbside has shocked Australians
UCLA Adds a Title to the ‘Conference of Champions.’ Will It Be Its Last?
Yankees General Manager Returns on Four-Year Contract
Hertz to Pay $168 Million to Customers Who Say They Were Falsely Accused of Auto Theft
‘Bigg Boss’ OTT winner Divya Aggarwal gets engaged to Apoorva Bhatgaonar months after her breakup with Varun Sood: Pics
DailyMail.com reveals where the cast of Cheers are following Kirstie Alley’s death
‘The Flash’ is set to return in 2023, insider details
Unified and zero-tolerance approach can eventually defeat terrorism: India’s UN envoy Ruchira Kamboj at meeting over Iraq
Raheem Sterling ‘won’t return to England’s World Cup camp until his family is safe’ after burglary
From Star Trek to Scream Queens: A glimpse at Kirstie Alley’s remarkable film and TV career
Biden Administration Expands Protections for Haitian Migrants
Orion Conducts Return Powered Flyby – Artemis
What Is New York’s Greenest Borough? Probably Not The One You Think.
Florida Ex-Congressman Arrested Over Secret Contract With Venezuela
Zelenskiy warns Ukrainians of ’emergency blackouts’ after Russia’s fresh missile strikes
Four friends are found guilty of kidnapping British ex-public schoolboy, 26, in Italy in ransom plot
Warnock Claims Momentum in Georgia, as Walker Banks on Election Day Turnout
Why made-up swear words are ideal around young ears
North Carolina governor says damage at substations that left 35,000 without power was intentional
Governor Calls Attack on Power Stations a ‘New Level of Threat’
Governor Calls Attack on Power Stations a ‘New Level of Threat’
Michael Avenatti Gets 14-Year Sentence For Stealing Millions From Clients
Neighbors of Fame star Irene Cara says she became a hermit during her final years living in Florida
New Orleans Saints vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – NFL LIVE: Play-by-play action