British astronomers are locked in fight over £400,000 fortune of stargazer who discovered a comet

Author: Yuvi November 24, 2022


British stargazers are locked in a bizarre court fight over the £400,000 fortune of a celebrated astronomer who left everything to his ‘best mate’ in his will – but didn’t say who that was.

Amateur astronomer Roy Panther found national fame in 1980 when he discovered a comet with a home-made telescope from his suburban semi.

The discovery earned him a mention in the record books and he also featured on the long-running BBC astronomy show ‘The Sky at Night’ when he was interviewed by Sir Patrick Moore.

Mr Panther, who died in 2016, had planned to leave almost all his worldly goods to the British Astronomical Association (BAA), but a bitter court row has since erupted after the discovery of a new will written on his deathbed.

The hand-written document simply promises everything to ‘my best mate’ – and now lifelong friend and fellow star-gazer Alan Gibbs is fighting in court to prove he is the ‘mate’ and so the rightful heir.

Astronomer Roy Panther (pictured) found national fame in 1980 when he discovered a comet with a home-made telescope from his home.

He made his discovery on Christmas Day in 1980 when he spotted the faint signs of what would become 'Comet Panther' (pictured) from his home in Walgrave, Northants

He made his discovery on Christmas Day in 1980 when he spotted the faint signs of what would become ‘Comet Panther’ (pictured) from his home in Walgrave, Northants

Mr Panther's former suburban semi (pictured) where he spotted the comet with a home-made telescope

Mr Panther’s former suburban semi (pictured) where he spotted the comet with a home-made telescope

However, the case – to be fought next year – is being contested by the BAA, which says simply stating ‘my best mate’ is not enough to make a valid will and that Mr Panther was too frail and ill at the time to fully understand what was he doing anyway.

Mr Panther, who was 90 when he died in hospital in October 2016, was an enthusiastic amateur astronomer, who had created an observatory using home-built equipment at his Northamptonshire home.

He made his amazing discovery on Christmas Day in 1980 when he spotted the faint signs of what would become ‘Comet Panther’ from his home in Walgrave, Northants.

He was conducting a ‘systematic search’ of the night sky when he spotted the new comet in the far north, within in the constellation of Draco.

It was his first success after over 600 hours of searching and he later said in a television interview that it would mean his name would not be ‘forgotten to posterity.’

In 1986, he made a will, leaving almost all of his fortune, including his home in Old Road, Walgrave, to the BAA, of which he was a long-standing member.

Two friends got small cash sums, while another, Colin Eaton, was named executor of the will and was left £10,000 and Mr Panther’s optical and meteorological charts and equipment.

Mr Panther's friend Colin Eaton (pictured) was named executor of the will and was left £10,000, optical and meteorological charts and equipment.

Mr Panther’s friend Colin Eaton (pictured) was named executor of the will and was left £10,000, optical and meteorological charts and equipment.

But Mr Gibbs, also from Northampton, now claims that while in Northampton General Hospital before his death, Mr Panther had dictated a new will, leaving everything to him.

Dated September 11, 2016, the will, which Mr Gibbs says he transcribed on the instruction of his old friend, states that ‘if I die’ his estate would go to ‘my best mate,’ which Mr Gibbs says can only refer to him .

‘Mr Gibbs and the deceased were lifelong friends, having known each other for around 77 years,’ says his barrister, Chris Bryden, in documents filed at Central London County Court ahead of next year’s trial.

‘They shared a keen interest in astronomy and together established an observatory. The deceased purchased the premises and Mr Gibbs provided equipment for this observatory.

‘It is admitted and averred that the 2016 will does not refer to Mr Gibbs by name but rather to ‘best mate’. However the compelling inference is that the deceased by this phrase was referring to Mr Gibbs.

‘The deceased dictated the terms of the 2016 will to Mr Gibbs. It is therefore natural that he used a colloquial phrase, rather than identifying him by name.

‘The ordinary and natural meaning of the phrase ‘best mate’ and the intention of the deceased was clearly to refer to Mr Gibbs.’

But the BAA denies that the 2016 document was duly executed because it did not actually name the beneficiary.

They are also raising questions over how it was witnessed, as well as insisting Mr Panther was very frail and vulnerable at the time and did not fully understand what he was doing.

Sir Patrick Moore (pictured), who interviewed Mr Panther, recording the 650th 'The Sky at Night' for BBC television at his home in Selsey, West Sussex

Sir Patrick Moore (pictured), who interviewed Mr Panther, recording the 650th ‘The Sky at Night’ for BBC television at his home in Selsey, West Sussex

Before the will was written, the BBA say, he had suffered a fall at home and been hospitalized and was said by medical staff to be ‘finding it difficult to understand’ communications.

He also had dementia, say the BBA, and there had also been concerns about his welfare as he had been leaving his front door unlocked, allowing people to come and go uninvited.

Although previously an ‘articulate’ man, he had been described as ‘very confused’ in hospital, where his only visitor was Mr Gibbs.

‘The deceased was extremely vulnerable from 30 August 2016 till he passed away,’ says the BAA’s barrister Mukhtiar Singh.

‘At the time of making the handwritten note, the deceased lacked capacity and did not understand the nature and effect of it.

‘The deceased had serious communication difficulties due to his hearing and/or he was unable to make decisions for himself due to his cognitive impairment.’

But Mr Bryden says that is only part of the story, since other medical notes suggest that Mr Panther’s condition had improved while in hospital.

He was said to be ‘bright and chatty’ and talking in sentences days before the will was made and ‘bright and communicative’ on the day it was written.

‘The deceased himself dictated the terms of the 2016 will and was aware of the nature and extent of his property and clearly expressed that he wished for Mr Gibbs to receive the same,’ Mr Bryden added.

The battle over the 2016 will is set to be heard during a three-day trial at Central London County Court next year, but reached the court last week for a short planning hearing dealing with the evidence to be heard.

Judge Alan Johns KC granted an application for medical evidence to be given at the trial by doctors relating to Mr Panther’s capacity to make a will at the time he was in hospital.

24 November, 2022, 6:14 pm

News Cinema on twitter News Cinema on facebook

Thursday, 24th November 2022

More Stories
Queen was privately ‘devastated’ by Prince Harry and Meghan Markle lashing out at the royal family
Gmail creator predicts total disruption for Google as chatbot ChatGPT challenges tech giant monopoly
World Test Championship 2023: Pakistan’s defeat puts India in driver’s seat to reach final, here’s why
Shylah Rodden’s Melbourne Royal Show rollercoaster crash sees ride operator quit carnivals
Pakistani Actress Hania Ameer Mobbed By Unruly Crowd, Actress Loses Her Cool – Watch Viral Video
After swimsuit look, Priyanka Chopra stuns in hot pink gown for Bulgari event in Dubai – pics
Black and Spanish: A National Team Starts to Reflect All of Its Nation
Cruise ship passengers open up about the moment a rogue wave struck the vessel killing American woman
They thought I was fat: Shilpa Shirodkar reveals why she lost ‘Saiya Saiya’ to Malaika Arora
Hansika Motwani looks radiant in a red bridal lehenga and finally shares her wedding clicks with husband Sohail Katuria!
Kirstie Alley’s death prompts social media users to Tweet ‘you had a good go at it’
Amidst Balenciaga’s controversial ad campaign, Malacca Aurora was party-shy wearing the brand’s dress!
Kirstie Alley’s final TV appearance: Late actress starred on The Masked Singer in April
Kirstie Alley once pined for her costars John Travolta and Patrick Swayze
Happy Birthday Jasprit Bumrah: Watch wife Sanjana Ganesan’s romantic message on the pacer’s special day
‘Drop Dead Gorgeous’ actor Kirsty Alley dies aged 71 after battle with cancer
Why this plain photo of a household bin sitting on a kerbside has shocked Australians
UCLA Adds a Title to the ‘Conference of Champions.’ Will It Be Its Last?
Yankees General Manager Returns on Four-Year Contract
Hertz to Pay $168 Million to Customers Who Say They Were Falsely Accused of Auto Theft
‘Bigg Boss’ OTT winner Divya Aggarwal gets engaged to Apoorva Bhatgaonar months after her breakup with Varun Sood: Pics
DailyMail.com reveals where the cast of Cheers are following Kirstie Alley’s death
‘The Flash’ is set to return in 2023, insider details
Unified and zero-tolerance approach can eventually defeat terrorism: India’s UN envoy Ruchira Kamboj at meeting over Iraq
Raheem Sterling ‘won’t return to England’s World Cup camp until his family is safe’ after burglary
From Star Trek to Scream Queens: A glimpse at Kirstie Alley’s remarkable film and TV career
Biden Administration Expands Protections for Haitian Migrants
Orion Conducts Return Powered Flyby – Artemis
What Is New York’s Greenest Borough? Probably Not The One You Think.
Florida Ex-Congressman Arrested Over Secret Contract With Venezuela
Zelenskiy warns Ukrainians of ’emergency blackouts’ after Russia’s fresh missile strikes
Four friends are found guilty of kidnapping British ex-public schoolboy, 26, in Italy in ransom plot
Warnock Claims Momentum in Georgia, as Walker Banks on Election Day Turnout
Why made-up swear words are ideal around young ears
North Carolina governor says damage at substations that left 35,000 without power was intentional
Governor Calls Attack on Power Stations a ‘New Level of Threat’
Governor Calls Attack on Power Stations a ‘New Level of Threat’
Michael Avenatti Gets 14-Year Sentence For Stealing Millions From Clients
Neighbors of Fame star Irene Cara says she became a hermit during her final years living in Florida
New Orleans Saints vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – NFL LIVE: Play-by-play action
Japan fans again win plaudits for picking up rubbish after defeat to Croatia at Qatar World Cup
Winklevoss twins owed $900m by broker that lost out in FTX crash