‘Giant Backfire’: Trump’s Demand for Special Master Is Looking Like a Mistake

Author: Yuvi September 29, 2022

'Giant Backfire': Trump's Demand for Special Master Is Looking Like a Mistake


WASHINGTON — Former President Donald J. Trump’s request that a judge intervene in the criminal investigation into his hoarding of government documents by appointing a special master increasingly looks like a significant blunder, legal experts say.

“Maybe from Trump’s point of view, creating delay and chaos is always a plus, but this has the feel of a giant backfire,” said Peter M. Shane, a legal scholar in residence at New York University and a specialist in separation-of -powers law.

Initially, Mr. Trump’s demand that an outside arbiter sift through the materials the FBI seized from his Florida estate seemed to turn in his favor. His lawsuit was assigned to a judge he had appointed, Aileen M. Cannon of the Southern District of Florida, who surprised legal experts by granting his request.

In naming a special master suggested by Mr. Trump’s lawyers, she effectively froze the Justice Department’s investigation and gave the arbiter a broad mandate. The judge, Raymond J. Dearie of Federal District Court for the Eastern District of New York, would filter the materials not just for attorney-client privilege, which is not unusual, but also for executive privilege, which is unprecedented.

But Mr. Trump’s apparent triumph would prove short-lived. An appeals court ruling last week and a letter the Justice Department filed late Tuesday about subsequent complaints his legal team has apparently filed under seal to Judge Dearie suggest that the upsides to obtaining a special master are eroding and the disadvantages swelling.

A lawyer for Mr. Trump did not respond to a request for comment.

The appeals court freed the Justice Department to resume using about 100 documents marked as classified in its investigation, while telegraphing that the court thought Judge Cannon likely erred by appointing a special master.

In blocking part of Judge Cannon’s order, the appeals court panel, including two Trump appointees, allowed investigators to again scrutinize the material that poses by far the gravest legal threat to Mr. Trump. Potential crimes include unlawful retention of national security secrets, obstruction and defying a subpoena demanding all sensitive records that remained in his possession.

But the Justice Department acquiesced for now to the remainder of the special master process, meaning that an outside arbiter would still assess some 11,000 unclassified records and other items seized from Mr. Trump’s Florida compound, Mar-a-Lago.

Since that review is no longer delaying or diverting the criminal inquiry, it is not clear what benefits remain for Mr. Trump.

For one, a special master will cost a lot of money. Judge Cannon rejected Mr. Trump’s proposal that taxpayers should foot half the bill of the review, instead saying he would be solely responsible.

That includes the full cost of a vendor who will scan all the materials, as well as support staff for Judge Dearie, like an assistant who bills $500 an hour. Mr. Trump will also have to pay his own lawyers’ fees as they filter thousands of pages of records and then litigate disputes about which ones can be withheld as privileged.

And far from indulging Mr. Trump, as his lawyers likely hoped in suggesting his appointment, Judge Dearie appears to be organizing the document review in ways that threaten to swiftly puncture the former president’s defenses.

For example, the judge has ordered Mr. Trump to submit by Friday a declaration or affidavit that lists any items on the inventory “that plaintiff asserts were not seized” in the search.

But if Mr. Trump acknowledges that the FBI took any documents marked as classified from his personal office and a storage room at Mar-a-Lago, as the inventory says, that would become evidence that could be used against him if he was later charged with defying a subpoena .

Requiring Mr. Trump’s lawyers to verify or object to the inventory also effectively means making them either affirm in court or disavow a claim Trump has made in public: his allegation that the FBI planted fake evidence. While it is not a crime to lie to Fox News viewers or on social media, there are consequences to lying to a court.

Essentially, Judge Dearie is telling Mr. Trump’s legal team “to put up or shut up,” said Julie O’Sullivan, a Georgetown University professor of white-collar law.

Late Tuesday, the Justice Department indicated to Judge Dearie that Mr. Trump’s lawyers were balking at his request that their client verify the property inventory at this stage, before the documents could be categorized or reviewed for privilege. They apparently expressed such objections in a document filed under seal.

“They thought it was a win to win the first battle, but they didn’t think through what winning that battle would mean with any reputable judge who is appointed as special master,” Ms. Sullivan said. “They can’t anticipate that every judge will give them a complete pass despite the law. It was a political or a public relations strategy, not a legal one.”

Another issue centers on Mr. Trump’s public insistence that he declassified everything he took to Mar-a-Lago, a claim for which no credible evidence has emerged.

His lawyers have not repeated that claim in court. They have instead merely insinuated that he might have done so by emphasizing that a president has broad declassification powers without asserting that he actually used them on the files.

At a hearing this month, Judge Dearie said that Mr. Trump’s legal team would need to submit evidence of any declassification — like an sworn declaration or affidavit — or he would conclude that they remained classified.

“I guess my view of it is,” he said, “you can’t have your cake and eat it.”

In exempting the documents marked as classified from the special master’s review, the appeals court also focused on the disconnect. There was “no evidence that any of these records were declassified,” the three-judge panel wrote, noting that Mr. Trump’s lawyers had “resisted providing any evidence that he had declassified any of these documents.”

The Justice Department’s letter indicated that Mr. Trump, through his lawyers, is chafing at other orders from the special master.

For example, Judge Dearie has said they must categorize each document Trump claims is subject to privilege. They are to say whether they mean attorney-client or executive privilege. If they claim executive privilege, then they must distinguish between records that are merely shielded from disclosure to people outside the executive branch and those the executive branch itself supposedly cannot review. They must also explain why each document qualifies for such status.

Judge Dearie is effectively trying to force Mr. Trump’s lawyers to confront a weakness in their theory that executive privilege is relevant to the case. Many legal experts doubt a former president can invoke the privilege against the wishes of the current president, preventing the Justice Department from reviewing executive branch materials in a criminal investigation.

But for now, Mr. Trump’s legal team evidently wants to say only that various items are privileged, leaving it at that.

For its part, the Justice Department appeared to relish Mr. Trump’s growing discomfort.

“Plantiff brought this civil, equitable proceeding,” it wrote. “He bears the burden of proof.”

29 September, 2022, 1:25 am

News Cinema on twitter News Cinema on facebook

Thursday, 29th September 2022

More Stories
FDA Considering New Approach to Blood Donation by Gay and Bisexual Men
Sen. John Barrasso calls for Biden’s non-binary nuclear was guru Sam Brinton to be ‘terminated’
Wormhole is created inside a quantum computer that ‘teleported’ a message from one side to the other.
Irish Rail worker who is paid £105,000 a year to ‘read the paper’ takes employers to court
Epstein Estate Agrees to Pay More Than $105 Million to US Virgin Islands
Mark Zuckerberg defends the company’s push into the metaverse, where he appeared with a bout of hiccups.
Former Adam Levine yoga instructor says 1992 attack ‘eerily similar’ to University of Idaho slayings
Biden Promises Protections for Nevada’s Spirit Mountain
Fyre Festival fraudster Billy McFarland launches new virtual PYRT festival
Andy Jassy says Amazon will allow the antisemitic film that Kyrie Irving tweeted to remain on sale for now.
Scooter Driver Who Struck and Killed Actress Gets Up to 3 Years
Pamela Rosenkranz Wins the High Line Plinth’s Third Commission
Royal Family news LIVE: William and Kate land in Boston for a three-day visit to the US
Powell says that rates will rise more and remain high ‘for some time.’
San Francisco Considers Allowing Use of Deadly Robots by Police
Life Science, Spacewalk Preps as Station Orbits Higher
NATO Nations Grow More Receptive to US Pleas to Confront China
Prince William and Kate Middleton land in Boston for US trip amid royal race row
New York Police Name a Chief Who Has Faced Internal Discipline
South Africa’s President, Cyril Ramaphosa, Faces Impeachment Hearing
Mother sparks furious debate after waxing her 10-year-old daughter’s face
Outcome in Oath Keepers Trial Could Hold Lessons for Coming Jan. 6 Cases
Elon Musk’s Neuralink to share progress of its brain chip tonight
Sam Brinton: Biden’s nuclear waste guru spoke at a spanking seminar weeks after bag theft
Could Theatrical Movies Shut Out Streamers for the Top Oscars?
17 Public Employees Charged in Schemes to Steal Covid Relief Funds
Deaths From Substance Abuse Rise Sharply Among Older Americans in 2020
White House ‘deeply concerned’ about Paul Whelan
‘Philadelphia is a war zone’: thug strolls up to parking official and shoots him in the head
Indian-origin doc slams ‘racist joke’ at British Curry Awards
Argentina’s World Cup Hangs in the Balance Against Poland
China completes world’s largest solar telescope array with 1.9-mile-wide ring of 313 dishes
Bigg Boss 16 Day 60 Updates: Housemates call Nimrit unfair for favoring Shiv and Soundarya in ranking task
FIFA World Cup 2022: Defending champion France lost to Tunisia
Mariah Carey offers fans opportunity to stay in her apartment BUT the star won’t even be there
House PASSES bill to stop a rail strike on December 9 after Biden asked Congress to step in
In Georgia, Walker’s Pace in the Finish Worries Republican Allies
Hiroshi Miyamura, Given Medal of Honor in Korean War, Dies at 97
Cops kill Illinois man and his grandpa while trying to stop younger man from stabbing his relative
A Resonant Topic in Georgia’s Senate Runoff: Insulin Prices
Spotify Wrapped drops but Apple Music Replay fans have it trending
The five ‘saboteurs’ trying to derail Kevin McCarthy’s Speaker bid: GOP leader’s allies push back