Judge Orders Release of Video Showing Attack on Paul Pelosi
SACRAMENTO — Footage of the attack on former US House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s husband will be released to the public after a judge on Wednesday denied prosecutors’ request to keep it secret.
Judge Stephen M. Murphy of San Francisco Superior Court ruled that there was no reason to keep the footage secret, especially after prosecutors played it in open court during a preliminary hearing last month, according to Thomas R. Burke, a San Francisco-based lawyer. who represented a host of news agencies in their attempt to access the evidence. The New York Times was among the news organizations seeking release of the footage.
The San Francisco District Attorney’s Office handed over the evidence to Judge Murphy on Wednesday. He asked the court clerk’s office to distribute it to the media, which could happen as soon as Thursday.
Ms. Pelosi’s husband, Paul, was asleep at the couple’s San Francisco home on Oct. 28 when someone broke in and beat him with a hammer. Prosecutors have charged David DePape, 42, in connection with the attack.
During a preliminary hearing last month, prosecutors played portions of Mr. Pelosi’s 911 call plus footage from Capitol Police surveillance cameras, body cameras worn by the two police officers who arrived at the house and video from Mr. DePape’s interview with the police.
But when news organizations asked for copies of that evidence, the San Francisco District Attorney’s Office refused to release it. The attack, which occurred just days before the 2022 midterm elections, prompted intense speculation from the public that fueled the spread of false information.
The district attorney’s office argued that releasing the footage publicly would only allow people to manipulate it in their quest to spread false information.
But the news agencies argued it was vital for prosecutors to publicly share their evidence that could debunk any false information swirling on the internet about the attack.
“You don’t eliminate the public right of access just because of concerns about conspiracy theories,” Mr. Burke said.
The news agencies that sought the release of the footage include The New York Times, The Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times, the San Francisco Chronicle, The Press Democrat, CNN, Fox News, CBS, ABC, NBC and KQED, an NPR- member radio station in San Francisco.
Mr. DePape pleaded not guilty last month to six charges, including attempted murder. Police have said Mr. DePape told them there was “evil in Washington” and he wanted to harm Ms. Pelosi because she was second in line to the presidency. His case is pending.