San Francisco Backtracks on Plan to Allow Police Robots to Use Deadly Force

Author: Yuvi December 7, 2022

San Francisco Backtracks on Plan to Allow Police Robots to Use Deadly Force

Facing backlash from activists and constituents, city supervisors in San Francisco on Tuesday backpedaled on a policy that would allow the police to use robots to deploy lethal force.

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors had originally advanced the policy by an 8-to-3 vote last week. Supporters said the measure would allow police to use a robot with lethal force in extreme circumstances, such as when a mass shooter or a terrorist is the focal threat.

But an outpouring of criticism from those who said the move would be too dangerous appeared to have changed supervisors’ minds before the second required vote, which typically mirrors the first. The reversal was a rarity in Bay Area politics.

“I’m feeling very grateful to all the community members and civil rights leaders who spoke up and successfully persuaded the board of supervisors to change course here,” Dean Preston, a supervisor who opposed the deadly robot policy in the first vote, said in interview.

The board on Tuesday voted 8 to 3 to amend the policy. While it will still allow the Police Department to use remote-controlled robots, a provision now states that the robots cannot be used with deadly force. The board unanimously approved the policy as amended.

The supervisors also sent the original deadly robot provision back to the board’s rules committee, which may hold public hearings on the matter and further consider it.

The Police Department did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment.

The policy was developed in response to a state law enacted last year that required law enforcement agencies across California to seek the approval of their local governing bodies to use military-style equipment.

The proposed policy last month propelled San Francisco into the forefront of a national debate about the use of weaponized robots in American cities, as the country confronts mass shootings — which some officers argue could be addressed with robots — and police brutality — which opponents of weaponized robots say could be worsened with them.

There is a precedent for robots being lethally used by law enforcement. In 2016, the Dallas Police Department ended a standoff with a gunman suspected of killing five officers by blowing them up with a bomb attached to a robot in what was believed to be the first lethal use of the technology by an American law enforcement agency.

Trying to garner support for the policy, David Lazar, assistant chief of the San Francisco Police Department, cited as an example the gunman who opened fire from his Las Vegas high-rise hotel room in 2017, killing 60 people in the deadliest mass shooting in modern US history.

Mayor London Breed, a Democrat, had expressed support for the original proposal last month. Her spokesman, Jeff Cretan, said in an email on Tuesday that Mayor Breed and her office understood that there would be “ongoing debate” about the robots and lethal force.

Most supervisors were quick to reverse course this week.

Mr. Preston said his fellow supervisors had heard from people in San Francisco and across the country that the proposed policy “was a mistake.”

On Monday, activists held a rally against the policy outside the steps of City Hall.

Mr. Preston said he believed the supervisors who changed their minds on Tuesday may not have “necessarily thought through all the implications” of the policy beforehand.

One of the supervisors who changed his mind, Gordon Mar, who oversees District 4, said in an interview that over the past week he had grown “increasingly uncomfortable” with enacting a law that would “give the power of human life to a remote control”. .”

“I do not think arming robots and giving them a license to kill will make us safer,” Mr. Mar said. “I think because of a lot of public comments and the attention that this has received nationally, it led me to think about the implications of this policy and the precedent that San Francisco could be setting.”

Hillary Ronen, the District 9 supervisor, said on Twitter that “common sense prevailed.”

Author: Yuvi

My name is Yuvi, I work as Sub Editor at

7 December, 2022, 9:17 am

News Cinema on twitter News Cinema on facebook

Wednesday, 7th December 2022

Latest Web Stories

More Stories
King Charles and Queen Consort Camilla host a Buckingham Palace reception
She Took On Atlanta’s Gangs. Now she may be coming for Trump.
Forget Pandemic Puppies. Meet the Inflation Chicken.
Education Firms That Serve Hasidic Schools Are Barred Amid Fraud Inquiry
Power to Punish LIV Golfers Faces a Legal Test in Europe
Kiara Advani and Sidharth Malhotra Hush-hush Royal Wedding in Jaisalmer? Check the date, venue and all the Buzz
Lambeth Council will repay 1,600 drivers it wrongly fined after admitting its road sign was unclear
Pathan Box Office Collection: SRK-Deepika Padukone and John Abraham starrer collects Rs 667 crore worldwide
Anand Pandit says the busy schedule of Big Bull is going on
Pakistan Blast: Peshawar Mosque Bomber who Killed Over 100 Wore Police Uniform; Cops Admit Security Lapse
Ranveer Singh, Alia Bhatt Starrer Rocky Aur Rani Ki Prem Kahani Pushed To July 28
Prosecutors subpoena dentist’s office for records of Leilani Simon accused of murdering her son
More pain for Brits as Bank of England is set to hike interest rates TODAY
Winter Storm Hits Texas, West Virginia, Several Other US States; Over 1,800 Flights Canceled
20 Rare Indian Baby Girl and Baby Boy Names Inspired by Love – Check Names and Exact Meanings
Twitter announces plans to start charging developers to access its application programming interface
Anjali Arora’s latest poignant video breaks the internet after MMS scandal – WATCH
ISIS bride Shamima Begum claims she met ISIS executioner Jihadi John
How Lamborghini-driving grifter conned dozens of investors out of $35m with fake weed business
Bank Of England Is Expected To Raise Rates Again
Australia to Replace Portrait of Queen Elizabeth II on its Banknote
Australia Is Removing The British Monarch From Its 5-Dollar Bill
Avatar: The Way of Water beat ‘The Avengers’ to become the 10th highest grosser of all time in the US.
Pamela Anderson is radiant at NYC party for her new Netflix doc Pamela, a Love Story
Rakhi Sawant cries uncontrollably saying ‘Marriage with Adil Khan is in danger’
Tunisha Sharma death case: Actor’s uncle demands inquiry into role of Sheesan’s relatives
US to Boost Military Role in the Philippines as Fears Over Taiwan Grow
Accountants say Trump might have as little as $30 million scattered across hundreds of bank accounts
Bernie Sanders labeled a hypocrite for charging $95 a ticket to attend event promoting his new book
Russian Diesel Is Europe’s New Embargo Target
Deepika Padukone wrote a happy birthday wish for sister Anisha
Tom Brady ‘filmed his retirement video days before his official announcement’…
Ex-Skid Row drug addict slams California’s politicians for not ‘incentivizing people to get sober’
LAX power outage stops TSA, causes potential flight delays
Ajay Devgan-Kajol’s daughter Nysa Devgan attends a party in a plunging neckline, her missing photo goes viral
NRL Nicho Hynes supports his mum at Gosford court as she faces charges for allegedly dealing heroin
US Drills Have Pushed Situation to ‘Extreme red-line’: North Korea Warns Biden; The White House Responds
Ananya Pandey helms Vikramaditya Motwane’s cyber thriller.
Dog mauling horror as a man’s chest is ‘PUNCTURED’ by a canine in Sydney’s south
Francesca Packer’s boyfriend Robert Bates chased by investors over wellness company
Cops investigating consensual murder-suicide of Pennsylvania woman and parents