Study reveals the breeds most likely to suffer from painful cranial cruciate ligament ruptures
Vets have revealed the dog breeds most at risk from painful cranial cruciate ligament (CCL) ruptures.
CCL ruptures are common with humans as well as dogs, with professional athletes and footballers, such as Alan Shearer and Roy Keane, suffering from the condition.
A study from the Royal Veterinary College’s (RVC) VetCompass Program looked at 1,000 dogs with CCL rupture cases and a random selection of 500,000 other dogs without the injury.
It revealed that Rottweilers were the dogs most at risk, being 3.66 times more likely to get the disease, with cockapoos being least at risk.
Most dogs see a gradual degeneration of the ligament, seeing a sudden onset of pain and lameness.
A study from the Royal Veterinary College (RVC) revealed the dog breeds most at risk for cranial cruciate ligament (CCL) rupture
Other dogs at high risk of the ailment were Bichon Frize, who were 2.09 times more likely to get a rupture, West Highland White Terries, who were 1.80 times more likely to get a rupture, and Golden Retrievers, who were 1.69 times more likely to To install breakup.
Those at lowest risk of ruptures include Chihuahas, at 0.31 times, Shih-tzu at 0.41 times and German Shepherd Dogs, at 0.43 times.
What is a cranial cruciate ligament rupture?
Cranial cruciate ligament (CCL) ruptures is one that affects both humans and dogs.
The CCL is an important ligament inside the knee joints of dogs which stops the knee bone moving in front of the thigh bone.
Rupture to the ligament can either happen progressively over time, weakening certain spots of the leg or can happen suddenly.
Symptoms of a CCL rupture include:
Lameness in the hind limbsKnee joining painDifficulty rising and jumpingOccasional clicking noises
Dr Anna Frykfors von Hekkel, Lecturer in Small Animal Surgery at the RVC and co-author of the paper, added: ‘This study helps to confirm suspicions we have held in the clinic, with recognition of breeds such as the West Highland White Terrier and Rottweiler being at increased risk of developing CCL disease.
‘It offers a valuable insight into how these patients are managed in general practice and factors that might influence that challenging decision.’
The age of the dog was also a factor that influenced how likely the animal was to get the disease, with dogs aged six to over the age of nine being more than three times more likely compared with dogs less than years old.
The research, published in The Veterinary Journal, hopes the findings will help dog owners and vets identify dogs who are most at risk to the problem.
Treating the issue is often based on surgical and non-surgical management.
The study, which was the largest epidemiological study to date looking at the disease, considered the treatment options and decided which dog breeds were more likely to have the issue surgically resolved.
Dogs who weighed over 44lbs (20kg) were more likely to go through surgery, whereas dogs who were insured were almost three times more likely to have surgery.
Labrador retrievers were the breed most likely to undergo treatment via surgery, with 48 percent of those diagnosed going under.
Rottweilers, on the other hand, only saw 15 percent of those diagnosed go through with surgery – despite being the breed most likely to get the disease.
An X-Ray of a dog with a CCL rupture, causing rear limb lameness in the dog
A mixed breed dog using an orthotic brace for a CCL knee injury, with its injury being held together with a sling
The dogs most at risk of cranial cruciate ligament rupture
Research from the Royal Veterinary College (RVC) looked into which dogs are most at risk of CCL:
Rottweiler 3.66 times at risk Bichon Frize 2.09 times at risk West Highland White Terrist 1.80 times at risk Golden Retriever 1.69 times at risk
Golden Retrievers were one of the dog breeds most likely to get the disease.
Older dogs over the age of nine, and those with other clinical problems at the time of diagnosis were also less likely to go through surgery.
Camilla Pegram, VetCompass PhD student at the RVC and lead author of the paper, said: ‘This study has used the power of ‘big data’ to robustly address the risk factors for cruciate ligament rupture diagnosis and management in dogs.
‘The factors affecting the decision to surgically or non-surgically treat dogs with cruciate rupture are now clearer, with future work underway to address the clinical outcomes of this decision.’
The researchers decided there were four main factors associated with how the disease was managed by vets.
These included the age of the dog, adult body weight, the owner’s insurance status and presence of other diseases.
Dr Dan O’Neill, Associate Professor in Companion Animal Epidemiology at the RVC and co-author of the paper, concluded: ‘After centuries of reshaping by mankind, dogs now come in over 800 distinct and recognizable breeds that each have its own unique pattern of health and disease.
‘This new study helps owners of breeds such as Rottweiler, Bichon Frize and West Highland White Terrier to understand that sudden lameness in a hindleg could indicate a ruptured cruciate ligament that needs urgent veterinary care.
‘VetCompass studies are empowering owners to understand their dog’s health better than ever before.’
How at risk is your dog to cranial cruciate ligament ruptures?
A new study carried out by the Royal Veterinary College revealed which dogs are most at risk to cranial cruciate ligament ruptures.
Rottweiler – 3.66 times more likely Bichon frize – 2.09 times more likely West Highland white terrier – 1.8 times more likely Golden retriever – 1.69 times more likely Yorkshire retriever – 1.53 times more likely Jack Russell terrier – 1.43 times more likely English springer spaniel – 1.4 times more likely Border terrier – 1.34 times more likely Beagle – 1.24 times more likelyStaffordshire bull terrier – 0.88 more likely Purebreed (other not specified) – 0.69 times more likelyLabrador retriever – 0.66 times more likelyCocker spaniel – 0.63 times more likelyBorder collie – 0.55 times more likelyFrench bulldog – 0.50 times more likelyGerman shepherd – 0.43 times more likely Shih-tzu – 0.41 times more likelyChihuahua – 0.31 times more likelyCockapoo – 0.26 times more likely