Supreme Court dismisses plea seeking stay on release of Alia Bhatt starrer Gangubai Kathiawadi

Author: Yuvi February 24, 2022

Supreme Court dismisses plea seeking stay on release of Alia Bhatt-starrer Gangubai Kathiawadi


New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Thursday dismissed a petition seeking a stay on the release of Bollywood film Gangubai Kathiawadi. The Alia Bhatt-starrer, produced by Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s Bhansali Production Pvt Ltd, is set to release on Friday.

A bench of Justices Indira Banerjee and JK Maheshwari dismissed Babuji Raoji Shah’s plea against the Bombay High Court order against various reliefs such as interim stay on the film’s release. “The SLP has been dismissed. Reasons behind it,” the bench said.

Initially, senior advocate A Sundaram, appearing for the filmmakers, told the bench that it would not be practically possible to change the name of the film, as suggested by it, as they would have to approach the censor board again.

He said that there cannot be any objection to the name of the film as the film has been given a censor certificate.

He questioned the whereabouts of the petitioner and said that Shah claims to be the adopted son of Gangubai without any evidence. “There is no ground for adoption. The person is claiming to be the adopted son and there is no prima facie evidence. He is a third party and has shown only one ration card to substantiate his claim. Proof of this Not even a whisper other than the ration card,” said Sundaram.

The senior counsel further submitted that prima facie nothing has been shown to the court to prove anything defamatory in the film. Sundaram said the entire case is based on a 2011 book which he did not consider challenging at that time. He said, “The book was “The Mafia Queens of Bombay”. Our film glorifies the woman for what she has achieved.

Sundaram said there are judgments to show that the right to defamation ends with the death of a person.

He said, “When I produce a film of a public figure who died 40 years ago, we’re trying to show what a great woman she was. If she lives in a red light area and She achieves great heights, so I am praising her more.”

The bench then asked, “What if there are condolences in the family?”

Sundaram replied that they are not family.

Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for the filmmakers, also argued that the film was not derogatory at all and glorified Gangubai’s character as to how she rose from a background and became an activist.

He said, “We have the certification of the film, it is ready for release. It is really out of our hands.”

Rohatgi also questioned the timing of the petition and asked, “Why is there a gap of nine months to challenge the Bombay High Court’s decision?

Advocate Rakesh Singh, appearing for the petitioner, argued that not only the individual but also the family members are affected by defamation. “They say the film is in the book and if the book is defamatory then the film is defamatory… The book says that he was having an affair and then he was pushed into a brothel in Kamathipura. This is also shown in the promo. ..The dialogue in the film is also defamatory to the victim.”

The bench then said that they have to establish a strong prima facie case on the basis of the status and merit of the case.

Shah had earlier moved the High Court seeking an order restraining the authors/publishers of the novel from making any third party rights over his mother’s (Gangubai Kathiawadi) life or writing any other story. He also demanded a ban on the release of the film ‘Gangubai Kathiawadi’.

The High Court, in its order passed on July 30 last year, had dismissed the application holding that any material of defamatory nature dies with the death of that person. “The appellant (Shah) has to demonstrate that he is the adopted son of the deceased Gangubai Kathiawadi, which he prima facie failed to do,” the high court said. Can be brought in court by any person provided he has made a claim for defamation.

The High Court had held that merely because the appellant is claiming to be the son of such person, prima facie it cannot be inferred that he has a legal right to show enjoyment.

Earlier, a lower court had dismissed Shah’s defamation suit, leading to an appeal in the high court, which also refused to grant him any interim relief.

live TV

24 February, 2022, 6:11 pm

News Cinema on twitter News Cinema on facebook

Thursday, 24th February 2022

More Stories
Sydney event planner shares biggest wedding styling dos and don’ts and budget alternatives
Hospital parking fees scandal continues as analysis shows one site charges £76 A DAY
After Hitting No. 62, Aaron Judge Acknowledges Pressure of Chase
Foreign nurses who fail English test can still be hired by NHS
Moment police swoop on house of devout catholic mother over ‘malicious online posts’
On Dussehra and Diwali, this Greater Noida village greets Ravana!
Heavyweight boxing world champion Mike Tyson winds back the clock with an impressive training video
Canberra rape trial: Brittany Higgins texts against Bruce Lehrmann sent to Ben Dilaway
Durga Puja 2022: Navya Nanda Plays Dhaak And Dances At Pandal
Tory conference live: Liz Truss prepares to make keynote speech to try and unite warring Tories
Terrifying moment speeding Maserati stolen by three Florida teens hits 123 mph before losing control
The end of Prince Harry and Meghan’s Netflix series?
Commonwealth Games 2026: Shooting returns, golf set to debut and women’s cricket intact for Victoria
Shellharbour council’s Reddall Reserve playground slide ‘dangerous’ as young Tailah Smith breaks leg
Sussan Ley: Australians face cost of living crisis before Christmas – Anthony Albanese doing NOTHING
OPEC and Russia meet today, with a big cut in oil output on the table.
Dussehra 2022: Ravana’s 10 Heads and What They Mean
Pike County massacre suspects attended the funeral of one of the eight victims they allegedly killed
‘Rest easy little soulja’: Family mourns mystery death of boy, 12, as vile trolls attack him
Rainbow fentanyl pills that resemble candy are found in LEGO box – as DEA warns parents
Hrithik Roshan and Ladylove Saba Azad attend Richa Chadha-Ali Fazal’s wedding reception, pose for shutterbugs together – WATCH
How to Honor a New Yorker? Name a Street After Them.
Shylah Rodden Rebel Coaster rollercoaster victim’s touching tribute to father Alan Rodden
Online retail giant Amazon pauses recruiting for corporate roles to rein in costs
Jeremy Lin Finally Loves ‘Linsanity’ Just As Much as You Do
The Eagles’ Architect Always Has a Plan B, but Plan A Is Working
Ravana Dahan on Vijayadashami 2022: Timing, Effigy Burning, Weapon Worship, Celebrations and Significance
Winner of Cleveland fishing tournament says he hopes duo who allegedly cheated get max punishment
Treasurer Jim Chalmers hints Stage Three tax cuts could be dumped after UK dumps plan
LePage Stumbles on Abortion Questioning in Maine Governor’s Debate
Election Software Executive Arrested on Suspicion of Theft
Netflix’s Jeffrey Dahmer series fact-checked: Journalist exposes which parts of the show are fake
Kanye WALKS BACK criticism of Vogue editor who called his White Lives Matter fashion show ‘violence’
Wild Cards: The Mets Are Officially Eliminated in the NL East
Ignore Adipurush trends on social media, netizens outraged by Om Raut’s portrayal of Ramayana; ‘Bollywood’s Hanuman looks Muslim…’
Mickleham Victoria Covid quarantine center closes after it cost $580million to build
Manhattan apartment sales FELL 18% in the third quarter – the first drop since 2020
Happy Dussehra 2022: Vijayadashami Whatsapp Messages, Wishes, Wishes and Quotes
Trump says National Archives should return files seized in Mar-a-Lago raid
Texas mayor forced to apologize after appearing to fall asleep during police officer’s funeral
Amazon Suspends Workers After Protest Over Warehouse Fire